Is America an IDEA or CULTURE Heres the NATIONALIST Answer

Author:

Video Creator’s Channel Dr. Steve Turley

author link

So Is America Creedal Or Tribal Are We

fundamentally an idea or we? A nation is America creed or culture or is it both let me know what you think in the comments below Because frankly in an effort to dismiss the current rise of nationalist populism. Many in our intellectual class are asking this question and I need not tell you which side they’re coming down on it is fashionable. It certainly has been fashionable to push against the rise of the new nationalism by asserting that America is fundamentally not a nation, not a culture, not a religion or an ethnicity. No America’s a Creed yeah you’ve heard it often enough. I’m sure we are the only country on the planet that was founded on an idea rather than an ethnicity or culture, religion or tradition, and so this whole America first nonsense that Trump is pushing actually.

Does Great Damage Irreparable Harm To

the true notion of what America really is so what do you think well? We’re going to take a deep dive into that question and come out on the other side. I believe with some very striking clarity. I think you’ll find it all very enriching but first let’s give a huge shout out to the sponsor this video and that’s our very very good friends over at American values investments now for over 15 years American values. Investments has provided patriotic Americans the opportunity to invest in stocks of companies that they believe best embody. America’s founding values their stock portfolios similar to mutual funds allow investors to save for retirement all the while supporting companies that best reflect the values that most Americans cherished values like integrity and caring encourage now of course, there’s risk in the stock market and the sad.

Does Not Constitute An Endorsement, But If You

want to learn how your investments can reflect timeless American values well then check them out in American values calm or just click on the link below you’ll be glad you did all right, so we’ve asked this question before I’ve been asked this question where do I stand on this whole notion that America is fundamentally an idea or a nation is America, a Creed or a culture and I was reminded of this when I came across an article entitled America creedal or tribal and it was written by the Georgetown_University” target=”_blank” rel=”noreferrer noopener”>Georgetown University Professor Paul Miller. Now I’ve got to be honest you know whenever I see the word professor you know my radars goes up I’m a little suspicious since the culturally Marxist infested University hasn’t been the most hospitable place for nationalists conception period let alone in the United. States but I came across this question again when I sat through recently the debate that’s been posted on UK between the nationalist conservative Uram Hezonia and the New York Times columnist Brett Stevens Stevens like Miller argued that America is fundamentally an idea. America is fundamentally an idea reflective of the ideals of classical liberalism and what Abraham Lincoln famously spoke about when he said that America was a nation conceived in Liberty and dedicated the proposition. All men are created equal right that’s the general gist of this notion that America is fundamentally a belief a creed, an idea a proposition rather than a nation, a tribe and ethnicity culture custom tradition, so what should we make of that is America creedal or tribals.

Miller Put It There.

I want to start by saying that in my opinion okay the notion of what America is well it ought. to be relatively simple so that I mean there’s no question in America is uniquely founded or rooted in an idea as a were creed that all men are created equal. I mean who’s gonna argue with that but what seems to me and many others. What’s so equally obvious is that it’s an idea that is rooted and I think undeniably so it’s an idea that’s rooted that comes to us through a highly definite history.

I Mean The Liberal Admits This

this this liberal admits the American ideals in fact rooted in classical liberalism, which is a belief system that’s inescapably culturally and historically contingent the idea that we are a nation conceived in Liberty and dedicated to the proposition that all men are created equal has a history to it a very definite history in a very definite culture, particularly an Anglo Protestant culture. This is what. Russell Kirk argued in his roots of American order the roots of American order. According to Kirk are founded in Athens Jerusalem in Rome and they make their way through London and are codified in Philadelphia. So our philosophical, moral and judicial foundations are developed in a very definite geography and history.

So The Question Of Whether America

is an idea or nation. I think is a rather uncomplicated one in the sense that the most reasonable obvious answer would appear to be well. Both it’s it’s a false dichotomy we’re both idea and nation creed and tribe, but here’s the problem proponents of the notion that America is an idea not a nation fully acknowledged that cultural and historical contingency, but they disregard it. They see it as frankly irrelevant and this is precisely what I read in this article by this Georgetown Professor. He and others that I’ve.

Heard Like Brett Stevens As Well In The

Princeton debate, they all see the Anglo Protestant cultural and historical context of the American ideal as inherently artificial. It’s it’s the parsley next to the steak okay it’s it’s the husk of the corn cultural and historical specificity function much like the rocket that sends the spaceship in outer space right. The rocket can be jettisoned at some point you can get rid of it and then let the spacecraft take over things like culture, custom and tradition particularly particularly our religious traditions function very much like that rocket right. They got the idea going they brought it to historical prominence. But because the idea of America is so transcultural and transnational cultural custom and tradition, they they assume an inherently artificial second-order status in relation to it now.

In Defense Of This Youll Notice A

rather strange inconsistencies surface on. Part of the Liberal and it’s an inconsistency that I think is highly relevant to the current rise the new nationalisms. I call it that’s going on all over the West’s because in defending this notion that America is fundamentally a creator, an idea that Garner‘s our loyalties irrespective of cultural religion. These proponents in either immediately or inevitably point to the fact that America has no inherent religion culture and so on precisely because America makes room for what all kinds of cultures and ethnicities and religions right. America is not defined by any dominant culture and religion precisely because it makes room for Catholics and Jews and Muslims and Hindus and all kinds of ethnicities which I find very fascinating because you’ll notice in that defense that the ethnicity and religion of the minority which is peripheral to America’s Founding in the rhetoric and the liberal that ethnicity.

Race Religion Suddenly Become Central To

the very idea of America did you catch that because I think it’s it’s so important to observe here. If a culture and religion is dominant, such as for example, the Anglo Protestant tradition here in the states proponents for the America is an idea notion consistently marginalize it. They undermine its social significance, its cultural contributions, the centrality that it played and plays in national identity. It’s no big deal. We don’t need it anymore.

The Dominant Coal Turn Religion Are Purposely Deflated

in terms of their significance. America’s right you’ve heard it. America is not a Christian nation. It’s I mean the founding fathers were all Dias after all, which by the way is emphatically not true, but you can see the rhetorical strategy right the dominant culture. The dominant religion is de-emphasized and deflated all the while at the same time.

Or Minority Cultures And Religions Are What In

this rhetoric? They’re suddenly inflated and radically emphasized as Paragons of America’s true meaning and identity and that’s not just happening in America that pattern that pattern of de-emphasizing and indeed, let’s be blunt even often degrading the dominant race, culture and ethnicity and religion all the while artificially inflating and celebrating minority races, ethnicities cultures and religions pervades the rhetoric of our globalist elite. Throughout the West. It’s actually technically known as emancipatory politics and it’s a thoroughly liberal globalist practice. It’s widely recognized that Western societies under the influence of our current globalist elite are radically asymmetrical when it comes to the right to celebrate difference or to assert one’s race as legitimate motivation for political action and the light cultural and religious minorities are consistently encouraged to indeed embrace and emphasize their ethnic and religious differences all the while. majority ethnicity and culture is shamed and virtue signaled into disparaging and hiding their cultural and ethnic uniqueness that’s emancipatory politics so I smell a rat every time.

  • nationalism
  • nationalisms
  • nationalist
  • nationalists
  • patriotic

I Come Across This Argument That

there’s no way America could be Anglo Protestant looking all these non-anglo Protestants that we’ve invited to be here as equal parts of our nation. You see this pattern of exclusion of the majority and the celebratory inclusion of the minority is precisely what is animating so much of the blowback against liberal globalism that we’re seeing all over the West today I couldn’t recommend more highly for your reading. The University of London. ‘s scholar Kaufman’s book called white shift on the cultural and religious blowback that’s going on throughout the West and responses radically unequal and asymmetrical application to civil rights and the right to ethnic and religious identity among majority population simply put it’s. asymmetry that cannot exist indefinitely and it won’t so that’s my first large point here so to summarize I think there’s a hidden contradiction in the notion that America is an idea rather than a nation and that hidden contradiction is that race and religion are indeed central for the liberal to the foundational idea of America, but it turns out to be minority races minority cultures minority religions that are now so central so that’s why I don’t think it’s so much a matter of whether culture is intrinsic to the American ideal.

I Think It Comes Down To

which culture right is it the majority culture that turns out to be the epitome of the nationalist ideal or is it minority cultures that are the epitome of the liberal ideal either way culture and religion and race remains central to both the liberal and nationalist conception of America. And then this leads me to my second point here my second and final point to very large points here and that’s insisting on the separation of the idea from nation. You know Creed from culture and I see this as little more than a continuation of the absurd dichotomy between mind and body that so plagued Western Scholasticism Since Descartes in the 17th century, Descartes had the famous Maxim Cachito ergo zoom I think therefore I am’ and Western. Scholarship has been deeply influenced by the idea that humans are fundamentally thinking beings not bodies so one of the methods of analysis that the economy well at least many in the Academy are repenting up is I tied the dichotomy between theory and practice.

  • religion ethnicity america creed
  • tribal fundamentally idea nation america
  • push rise new nationalism asserting
  • america fundamentally nation culture religion
  • nationalist conception america leads second

So As Scholars Were Very Prone To

examining brains rather than bodies right we love theories and are not particularly partial to practices We’re more. comfortable dealing with ideas over institutions and fortunately, this dichotomy is beginning to wane in the universities where embodiment and practice theories are huge right now so this whole question of whether America is a Creed or a culture. I think it breaks down precisely at.

Summary

Is America creedal or tribal? Are we fundamentally an idea or we? A nation is America creed or culture or is it both let me know what you think in the comments below . We’re going to take a deep dive into that question and come out on the other side. I believe with some very striking clarity. I think you’ll find it all very enriching but first let’s give a huge shout out to the sponsor American values investments. American values.& Investments has provided patriotic Americans the opportunity to invest in stocks of companies that they believe best embody. America’s founding values their stock portfolios similar to mutual funds allow investors to save for retirement all the while supporting companies that best reflect the values that most Americans cherished values like integrity and caring encourage now of course, there’s risk in the stock market and the sad.& does not constitute an endorsement, but if you want to learn how your investments can reflect timeless American values well then check them out in American values . American values Investments…. Click here to read more and watch the full video